Sagicc/nanoGentzen-v3
Text Classification β’ 4.89M β’ Updated β’ 121
sample_id int64 1 240k | trajectory_id int64 1 255k | curriculum stringclasses 20
values | sequent stringlengths 6 247 | rule stringclasses 13
values | rule_idx int64 -100 10 | pivot int64 -100 31 | target_epistemic class label 3
classes | target_value float64 0 1 | root_sequent stringlengths 6 247 | trace_step int64 0 44 | total_trace_steps int64 1 45 | input_ids listlengths 5 237 | token_length int64 5 237 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
161,242 | 127,115 | policy_missing_premise | v8, (v27 => v2), ((v8 & v25) => v27) |- v2 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v8, (v27 => v2), ((v8 & v25) => v27) |- v2 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
84,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
84,
24,
9,
24,
46,
78,
81,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
83,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
78
] | 39 |
107,863 | 43,577 | policy_missing_premise | v18, v16, (v23 => v18), ((v9 & v16) => v21) |- v21 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v18, v16, (v23 => v18), ((v9 & v16) => v21) |- v21 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
85,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
82,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
77,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
78,
77
] | 47 |
119,793 | 62,277 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v26, v27, Q, v2, v7, v20, v27, v11, (v6 => Q), v2, (v22 => v21), v19, v3, v21, (v2 => ~v1), (S => v13), v25, v0, (v2 => v27), v22, v13, v10, v16, v15, (v4 => v11), v5, v18, R, (v24 => v1), ((v17 & v0) => v24), P, v8 |- v1 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v26, v27, Q, v2, v7, v20, v27, v11, (v6 => Q), v2, (v22 => v21), v19, v3, v21, (v2 => ~v1), (S => v13), v25, v0, (v2 => v27), v22, v13, v10, v16, v15, (v4 => v11), v5, v18, R, (v24 => v1), ((v17 & v0) => v24), P, v8 |- v1 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
67,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
46,
83,
88,
24,
46,
78,
12,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
86,
46,
82,
24,
8,
24,
67,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
... | 212 |
185,222 | 164,739 | policy_refutation_contradiction | (~v18 => ~v13), (v14 => v15), v24, v5, (v7 => v5), v26, v2, P, (v21 => P), v8, S, (v18 => v3), v10, v1, (v3 => v11), (v12 => v10), R, v27, v17, ~v18, v16, Q, (v19 => S), v9, v22, v15, v6, (v11 => v13) |- v13 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (~v18 => ~v13), (v14 => v15), v24, v5, (v7 => v5), v26, v2, P, (v21 => P), v8, S, (v18 => v3), v10, v1, (v3 => v11), (v12 => v10), R, v27, v17, ~v18, v16, Q, (v19 => S), v9, v22, v15, v6, (v11 => v13) |- v13 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
11,
46,
77,
84,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
77,
79,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
4... | 197 |
162,070 | 128,406 | policy_refutation_contradiction | (v7 => v3), v25, Q, (v2 => v12), v17, v22, v22, v5, R, v0, (S => v16), v26, (v21 => ~v10), (v14 => v22), v6, v9, v1, v15, v12, v13, v20, v11, v14, (P => v9), v16, ((v25 & v26) => v21), v19, v24, v27, v3 |- v10 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v7 => v3), v25, Q, (v2 => v12), v17, v22, v22, v5, R, v0, (S => v16), v26, (v21 => ~v10), (v14 => v22), v6, v9, v1, v15, v12, v13, v20, v11, v14, (P => v9), v16, ((v25 & v26) => v21), v19, v24, v27, v3 |- v10 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
67,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
78,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
68,
88,
24,
... | 201 |
190,439 | 172,886 | unrelated_premise | v16 |- R | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v16 |- R | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
82,
24,
5,
24,
68
] | 7 |
80,703 | 32,529 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v3, v11, R, (v20 => R), v12, v16, (v5 => ~S), v27, (v7 => P), (v10 => v12), P, (Q => v27), v8, (v18 => v16), (v26 => v5), ((v8 & v3) => v26) |- S | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v3, v11, R, (v20 => R), v12, v16, (v5 => ~S), v27, (v7 => P), (v10 => v12), P, (Q => v27), v8, (v18 => v16), (v26 => v5), ((v8 & v3) => v26) |- S | 0 | 1 | [
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
68,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
12,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
81,
24,
8,
24,
11,
69,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
... | 136 |
166,373 | 135,173 | policy_missing_premise | v3, S, v10, v16, (v26 => v5), (v13 => P), R, v19, v7, v25, v0, (v5 => v18), (v16 => v3), v23, R, v3, (v20 => R), v27, v20, (v2 => v24), (Q => v19), v9, v6, v17, P, v24, v4, v1, v8, Q, v15 |- v18 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v3, S, v10, v16, (v26 => v5), (v13 => P), R, v19, v7, v25, v0, (v5 => v18), (v16 => v3), v23, R, v3, (v20 => R), v27, v20, (v2 => v24), (Q => v19), v9, v6, v17, P, v24, v4, v1, v8, Q, v15 |- v18 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
79,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
82,
24,
8,
24,
46,
81,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
79,
24,
8,
24,
66,
87,
88,
24,
68,
88,
24,
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
46,
83,
88,
24,
46,
... | 186 |
113,367 | 52,230 | constructive_refutation | ~v5 |- v5 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | ~v5 |- v5 | 0 | 1 | [
11,
46,
81,
24,
5,
24,
46,
81
] | 8 |
229,842 | 234,600 | constructive_refutation | ~v26 |- (v26 & P) | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | ~v26 |- (v26 & P) | 0 | 1 | [
11,
46,
78,
82,
24,
5,
24,
86,
46,
78,
82,
24,
9,
24,
66,
87
] | 16 |
201,377 | 189,971 | policy_missing_premise | v0, v14, v24, P, v22, (v8 => v15), v17, v15, v3, v5, v18, v8, S, v4, (v9 => v5), v2, v23, (v27 => v16), v22, ((v24 & v12) => v27), v19, (v17 => v22), (v1 => v3), v6, v11, (v7 => v25), v15, v26, v25, v13, v20 |- v16 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v0, v14, v24, P, v22, (v8 => v15), v17, v15, v3, v5, v18, v8, S, v4, (v9 => v5), v2, v23, (v27 => v16), v22, ((v24 & v12) => v27), v19, (v17 => v22), (v1 => v3), v6, v11, (v7 => v25), v15, v26, v25, v13, v20 |- v16 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
80,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
66,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
... | 206 |
143,357 | 99,135 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v22, (v23 => v10), v12, v5, v16, v1, v15, v9, (v26 => v11), v7, Q, v4, (v19 => v16), (v11 => v14), (P => ~v14), P, R, v2, (v0 => v7), v21, v6, v20, (P => v22), v13, v10, v17, (v3 => Q), ((v24 & v6) => v26) |- v14 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v22, (v23 => v10), v12, v5, v16, v1, v15, v9, (v26 => v11), v7, Q, v4, (v19 => v16), (v11 => v14), (P => ~v14), P, R, v2, (v0 => v7), v21, v6, v20, (P => v22), v13, v10, v17, (v3 => Q), ((v24 & v6) => v26) |- v14 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
12,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
46,
77,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
46,
85,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
82,
24,
8,
24,
46,
... | 202 |
181,560 | 159,035 | policy_missing_premise | (v16 => v17), (v7 => v16), (v17 => v12) |- v12 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v16 => v17), (v7 => v16), (v17 => v12) |- v12 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
82,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
83,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
82,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
78,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
77,
78
] | 42 |
120,985 | 64,137 | policy_refutation_contradiction | (v15 => v24), v11, ((v26 & v11) => v25), v15, (v15 => ~v13), (v12 => v13), (v25 => v12), v24 |- v13 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v15 => v24), v11, ((v26 & v11) => v25), v15, (v15 => ~v13), (v12 => v13), (v25 => v12), v24 |- v13 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
80,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
78,
82,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
77,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
81,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
77... | 93 |
176,030 | 150,335 | peirce_law | 0 |- (((v16 => v9) => v16) => v16) | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | 0 |- (((v16 => v9) => v16) => v16) | 0 | 1 | [
12,
24,
5,
24,
86,
86,
86,
46,
77,
82,
24,
8,
24,
46,
85,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
82,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
82,
87
] | 30 |
45,908 | 18,528 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v25, v19, v27, v4, R, (v14 => v22), (v21 => v23), (v0 => v7), v8, (Q => ~v1), v2, v22, (v24 => v16), v12, v20, Q, v3, v16, v7, S, v23, (v11 => v25) |- v1 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v25, v19, v27, v4, R, (v14 => v22), (v21 => v23), (v0 => v7), v8, (Q => ~v1), v2, v22, (v24 => v16), v12, v20, Q, v3, v16, v7, S, v23, (v11 => v25) |- v1 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
24,
68,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
12,
24,
8,
2... | 146 |
209,329 | 202,442 | policy_missing_premise | v4, (v12 => v22), v25, v5, v16, v24, S, v11, P, v21, v10, v17, (v23 => v4), Q, (v15 => v24), v6, (v22 => v0), v26, v3, v8, v2, v19, R, v21, v7, (v8 => v19), v18, (R => v21), (S => v2), v20, v19 |- v0 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v4, (v12 => v22), v25, v5, v16, v24, S, v11, P, v21, v10, v17, (v23 => v4), Q, (v15 => v24), v6, (v22 => v0), v26, v3, v8, v2, v19, R, v21, v7, (v8 => v19), v18, (R => v21), (S => v2), v20, v19 |- v0 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
80,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
66,
88,
24,
46,
78,
77,
88,
24,
46,
... | 191 |
218,220 | 216,353 | open_kripke_countermodel | (v18 => v17) |- ((v11 => v18) | (v17 & v18)) | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v18 => v17) |- ((v11 => v18) | (v17 & v18)) | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
83,
87,
24,
5,
24,
86,
86,
46,
77,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87,
24,
10,
24,
86,
46,
77,
83,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87,
87
] | 41 |
144,996 | 101,702 | policy_missing_premise | ((v12 & v3) => v21), R, Q, (v2 => v11), v25, v3, v8, v8, v19, (v15 => v10), v18, v6, v24, v16, v11, v13, P, v5, v20, (v21 => v7), v11, v22, (v18 => v8), v14, (S => v24), v23, (v1 => v26), v10, v0, v26, v2 |- v7 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ((v12 & v3) => v21), R, Q, (v2 => v11), v25, v3, v8, v8, v19, (v15 => v10), v18, v6, v24, v16, v11, v13, P, v5, v20, (v21 => v7), v11, v22, (v18 => v8), v14, (S => v24), v23, (v1 => v26), v10, v0, v26, v2 |- v7 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
86,
46,
77,
78,
24,
9,
24,
46,
79,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
77,
87,
88,
24,
68,
88,
24,
67,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
77,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
84,
8... | 202 |
126,067 | 72,102 | constructive_refutation | v4, ~v11, (v16 => v4), (v5 => v11) |- v5 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v4, ~v11, (v16 => v4), (v5 => v11) |- v5 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
80,
88,
24,
11,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
82,
24,
8,
24,
46,
80,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
77,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
81
] | 37 |
126,331 | 72,524 | law_of_excluded_middle | 0 |- (v16 | ~v16) | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | 0 |- (v16 | ~v16) | 0 | 1 | [
12,
24,
5,
24,
86,
46,
77,
82,
24,
10,
24,
11,
46,
77,
82,
87
] | 16 |
158,847 | 123,390 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v24, v9, Q, v26, (v14 => v3), (v24 => ~v13), (S => v9), R, v21, v3, P, v18, v0, v5, (v6 => v13), (v12 => v11), (v20 => v8), v16, (v24 => v27), (v11 => v6), v1, v27, v8, v25, v4, (v10 => Q) |- v13 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v24, v9, Q, v26, (v14 => v3), (v24 => ~v13), (S => v9), R, v21, v3, P, v18, v0, v5, (v6 => v13), (v12 => v11), (v20 => v8), v16, (v24 => v27), (v11 => v6), v1, v27, v8, v25, v4, (v10 => Q) |- v13 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
46,
85,
88,
24,
67,
88,
24,
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
79,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
80,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
77,
79,
87,
88,
24,
86,
69,
24,
8,
24,
46,
85,
87,
88,
24,
6... | 185 |
210,723 | 204,623 | policy_missing_premise | v5, (v19 => v11), ((v16 & v5) => v19) |- v11 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v5, (v19 => v11), ((v16 & v5) => v19) |- v11 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
85,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
77,
87,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
77,
82,
24,
9,
24,
46,
81,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
85,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
77,
77
] | 41 |
124,321 | 69,360 | constructive_refutation | v7, ((v7 & v11) => ~v13), v2, v5, v11, v2, (v5 => v2), v25, (v12 => v5) |- v13 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v7, ((v7 & v11) => ~v13), v2, v5, v11, v2, (v5 => v2), v25, (v12 => v5) |- v13 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
83,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
83,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
77,
87,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
77,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
87,
88,
24,
4... | 74 |
192,888 | 176,738 | law_of_excluded_middle | 0 |- (v9 | ~v9) | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | 0 |- (v9 | ~v9) | 0 | 1 | [
12,
24,
5,
24,
86,
46,
85,
24,
10,
24,
11,
46,
85,
87
] | 14 |
237,866 | 249,978 | policy_missing_premise | v19, v10, (Q => v16), v0, v26, v9, v5, (S => v8), P, v25, v17, v17, v8, v14, v1, v3, v21, (v22 => v20), v24, (v10 => v17), (v11 => v26), v12, (v4 => v27), v23, (R => v22), v7, v16, v27 |- v20 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v19, v10, (Q => v16), v0, v26, v9, v5, (S => v8), P, v25, v17, v17, v8, v14, v1, v3, v21, (v22 => v20), v24, (v10 => v17), (v11 => v26), v12, (v4 => v27), v23, (R => v22), v7, v16, v27 |- v20 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
86,
67,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
82,
87,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
46,
85,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
86,
69,
24,
8,
24,
46,
84,
87,
88,
24,
66,
88,
24,
46,
78,
... | 183 |
141,316 | 95,942 | peirce_law | 0 |- (((v18 => v23) => v18) => v18) | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | 0 |- (((v18 => v23) => v18) => v18) | 0 | 1 | [
12,
24,
5,
24,
86,
86,
86,
46,
77,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87
] | 31 |
110,370 | 47,528 | double_negation_elimination | ~~v7 |- v7 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ~~v7 |- v7 | 0 | 1 | [
11,
11,
46,
83,
24,
5,
24,
46,
83
] | 9 |
131,587 | 80,729 | policy_missing_premise | (v8 => v14) |- v14 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v8 => v14) |- v14 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
80,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
77,
80
] | 16 |
237,142 | 248,406 | denying_antecedent | (v8 => v22), ~v8 |- ~v22 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v8 => v22), ~v8 |- ~v22 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
11,
46,
84,
24,
5,
24,
11,
46,
78,
78
] | 22 |
147,888 | 106,224 | constructive_refutation | ~Q, v14, (v3 => v25), (v18 => v3), v25, v14, (R => v5), (v25 => v14), (v5 => Q), v18 |- R | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | ~Q, v14, (v3 => v25), (v18 => v3), v25, v14, (R => v5), (v25 => v14), (v5 => Q), v18 |- R | 0 | 1 | [
11,
67,
88,
24,
46,
77,
80,
88,
24,
86,
46,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
81,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
80,
88,
24,
86,
68,
24,
8,
24,
46,
81,
87,
88,
24,
8... | 83 |
20,409 | 8,223 | policy_refutation_contradiction | (v14 => v7), v0, v15, v16, (v25 => ~v6), (v22 => v27), v27, v26, v19, v11, v7, (v2 => P), v21, v20, v3, (v5 => v15), P, (v9 => v25), v13, (v4 => v13), v9, S |- v6 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v14 => v7), v0, v15, v16, (v25 => ~v6), (v22 => v27), v27, v26, v19, v11, v7, (v2 => P), v21, v20, v3, (v5 => v15), P, (v9 => v25), v13, (v4 => v13), v9, S |- v6 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
83,
87,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
81,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
82,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
83,
87,
88,
24,
46,
7... | 154 |
221,979 | 222,263 | open_kripke_countermodel | ~v3 |- v18 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ~v3 |- v18 | 0 | 1 | [
11,
46,
79,
24,
5,
24,
46,
77,
84
] | 9 |
203,464 | 193,247 | policy_missing_premise | (v11 => v21), ((v26 & v0) => v22), (R => Q), Q, v15, (v20 => v15), v21, v0, (v10 => v14), v14 |- v22 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v11 => v21), ((v26 & v0) => v22), (R => Q), Q, v15, (v20 => v15), v21, v0, (v10 => v14), v14 |- v22 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
77,
87,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
78,
82,
24,
9,
24,
46,
12,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
68,
24,
8,
24,
67,
87,
88,
24,
67,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
12... | 94 |
9,568 | 3,884 | policy_missing_premise | v12, v14, v18, v20, v2, v0, ((v3 & v8) => v15), (v12 => v17), (v25 => v2), v24, (v15 => S), (v10 => v24), v22, v17, v5, v21, v24, (S => v11), v7, v27, v9, v3, (v6 => v27), P, (Q => P), v13, v10, v17, v23, R, v4 |- v11 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v12, v14, v18, v20, v2, v0, ((v3 & v8) => v15), (v12 => v17), (v25 => v2), v24, (v15 => S), (v10 => v24), v22, v17, v5, v21, v24, (S => v11), v7, v27, v9, v3, (v6 => v27), P, (Q => P), v13, v10, v17, v23, R, v4 |- v11 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
46,
77,
80,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
12,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
79,
24,
9,
24,
46,
84,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
78,
24,
8,
2... | 208 |
233,395 | 240,212 | policy_missing_premise | (v22 => v14), R, v9, v11, v2, v27, (v23 => S), (Q => v17), v18, v13, v14, (v6 => v21), (v10 => v20), v21, v8, S, v24, v20, v3, (v25 => v27) |- v17 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v22 => v14), R, v9, v11, v2, v27, (v23 => S), (Q => v17), v18, v13, v14, (v6 => v21), (v10 => v20), v21, v8, S, v24, v20, v3, (v25 => v27) |- v17 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
78,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
80,
87,
88,
24,
68,
88,
24,
46,
85,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
79,
24,
8,
24,
69,
87,
88,
24,
86,
67,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
83,
8... | 139 |
98,744 | 39,804 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v17, v18, ((v18 & v17) => ~P) |- P | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v17, v18, ((v18 & v17) => ~P) |- P | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
77,
84,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
83,
87,
24,
8,
24,
11,
66,
87,
24,
5,
24,
66
] | 32 |
140,196 | 94,182 | constructive_refutation | (v7 => v18), P, v6, (P => v6), ~v9, v7, (v18 => P), v6 |- v9 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v7 => v18), P, v6, (P => v6), ~v9, v7, (v18 => P), v6 |- v9 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87,
88,
24,
66,
88,
24,
46,
82,
88,
24,
86,
66,
24,
8,
24,
46,
82,
87,
88,
24,
11,
46,
85,
88,
24,
46,
83,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
84,
24,
8,
24,
66,
87,
88,
24,
46,
82,
24,
5,
24... | 56 |
143,204 | 98,898 | constructive_refutation | v17, (v17 => ~v10) |- v10 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v17, (v17 => ~v10) |- v10 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
83,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
77,
12,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
77,
12
] | 23 |
222,790 | 223,544 | policy_missing_premise | v4, (v7 => v13), v8, v3, v5, v0, v11, (v17 => v9), S, (v15 => v26), (v6 => v0), v13, v9, (v1 => v25), v16, v14, Q, v18, v10, P, v20, v26, (v21 => v11), v12 |- v25 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v4, (v7 => v13), v8, v3, v5, v0, v11, (v17 => v9), S, (v15 => v26), (v6 => v0), v13, v9, (v1 => v25), v16, v14, Q, v18, v10, P, v20, v26, (v21 => v11), v12 |- v25 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
80,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
85,
87,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
86,
... | 155 |
139,885 | 93,689 | denying_antecedent | (v5 => v15), ~v5 |- ~v15 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v5 => v15), ~v5 |- ~v15 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
11,
46,
81,
24,
5,
24,
11,
46,
77,
81
] | 22 |
103,889 | 41,880 | constructive_refutation | ~R |- (R & P) | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | ~R |- (R & P) | 0 | 1 | [
11,
68,
24,
5,
24,
86,
68,
24,
9,
24,
66,
87
] | 12 |
144,831 | 101,445 | constructive_refutation | v12, v7, ~v25, v24, (v20 => v7), (v7 => v12) |- (v25 & v11) | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v12, v7, ~v25, v24, (v20 => v7), (v7 => v12) |- (v25 & v11) | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
46,
83,
88,
24,
11,
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46,
83,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
78,
87,
24,
5,
24,
86,
46,
78,
81,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77... | 56 |
23,094 | 9,290 | policy_missing_premise | v17, v22, v7, v27, (v8 => v23), v5, (v10 => v3), (v25 => v12), v11, v20, (v26 => v17), (v4 => S), (v2 => v14), v23, Q, v3, v9, v12, v14 |- S | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v17, v22, v7, v27, (v8 => v23), v5, (v10 => v3), (v25 => v12), v11, v20, (v26 => v17), (v4 => S), (v2 => v14), v23, Q, v3, v9, v12, v14 |- S | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
46,
83,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
86,
46,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46,
79,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
81,
24,
8,
2... | 133 |
158,279 | 122,507 | double_negation_elimination | ~~P |- P | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ~~P |- P | 0 | 1 | [
11,
11,
66,
24,
5,
24,
66
] | 7 |
138,849 | 92,072 | policy_missing_premise | (v19 => v27), (v13 => v4), (P => v11), (v24 => v0), (v9 => v23), v0, v19, v23, v25, v1, v18, v27, v4, v15, v23, v3, v26, v2, v7, v27, v17, S, v21, R, (v10 => P), (v26 => v1), Q, v9, v22, v8, v20 |- v11 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v19 => v27), (v13 => v4), (P => v11), (v24 => v0), (v9 => v23), v0, v19, v23, v25, v1, v18, v27, v4, v15, v23, v3, v26, v2, v7, v27, v17, S, v21, R, (v10 => P), (v26 => v1), Q, v9, v22, v8, v20 |- v11 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
85,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
83,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
80,
87,
88,
24,
86,
66,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
77,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
85,
24,
8,
24,... | 193 |
182,868 | 161,070 | policy_refutation_contradiction | (~P => ~v16), ((P & v18) => v13), (v19 => v9), v26, (v25 => S), ~P, (v10 => v26), (v13 => v20), (v20 => v16), S, v18, (v0 => v2), v9 |- v16 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (~P => ~v16), ((P & v18) => v13), (v19 => v9), v26, (v25 => S), ~P, (v10 => v26), (v13 => v20), (v20 => v16), S, v18, (v0 => v2), v9 |- v16 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
11,
66,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
77,
82,
87,
88,
24,
86,
86,
66,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
79,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
85,
24,
8,
24,
46,
85,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
81,
24... | 130 |
143,927 | 100,025 | unrelated_premise | v12 |- Q | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v12 |- Q | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
78,
24,
5,
24,
67
] | 7 |
141,814 | 96,722 | policy_missing_premise | (v25 => v8), v0, v5, v3, v19, ((v11 & Q) => v25), v10, Q, v27, v9, v12, (S => v18), v4, v7, v24, v23, R, v15, v26, (v6 => R), (v16 => v15), v2, v20, v7, v21, (v5 => v7), v14, v23, v18, v22, (v20 => v23) |- v8 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v25 => v8), v0, v5, v3, v19, ((v11 & Q) => v25), v10, Q, v27, v9, v12, (S => v18), v4, v7, v24, v23, R, v15, v26, (v6 => R), (v16 => v15), v2, v20, v7, v21, (v5 => v7), v14, v23, v18, v22, (v20 => v23) |- v8 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
78,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
84,
87,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
77,
77,
24,
9,
24,
67,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
6... | 200 |
110,382 | 47,546 | policy_missing_premise | v9, (v11 => v9), v15, (v25 => v15), (v23 => v14), (v0 => v21), v17, v21, (v10 => v17) |- v14 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v9, (v11 => v9), v15, (v25 => v15), (v23 => v14), (v0 => v21), v17, v21, (v10 => v17) |- v14 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
85,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
85,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
80,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46... | 86 |
42,713 | 17,261 | policy_missing_premise | ((S & v22) => v15), (v4 => Q), S, (v17 => v10), Q |- v15 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ((S & v22) => v15), (v4 => Q), S, (v17 => v10), Q |- v15 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
86,
69,
24,
9,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
67,
87,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
12,
87,
88,
24,
67,
24,
5,
24,
46,
77,
81
] | 52 |
4,543 | 1,856 | policy_missing_premise | (v15 => v5), v4, v25, v2, v19, (v9 => R), v5, v10, ((v11 & Q) => v12), (v27 => v25), v0, (v1 => v8), v6, R, v7, v16, (v22 => v20), v11, v21, v26, v8, v20, v13 |- v12 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v15 => v5), v4, v25, v2, v19, (v9 => R), v5, v10, ((v11 & Q) => v12), (v27 => v25), v0, (v1 => v8), v6, R, v7, v16, (v22 => v20), v11, v21, v26, v8, v20, v13 |- v12 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
24,
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
86,
46,
85,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
77,
... | 158 |
146,978 | 104,792 | policy_missing_premise | P, (R => v0), (v9 => v15), (v20 => v3), v0, (v2 => v11), v22, v11, v3, v15, ((v17 & P) => v25), (v7 => v12), v12, v24, (v25 => v26), v4, (v26 => v10) |- v10 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | P, (R => v0), (v9 => v15), (v20 => v3), v0, (v2 => v11), v22, v11, v3, v15, ((v17 & P) => v25), (v7 => v12), v12, v24, (v25 => v26), v4, (v26 => v10) |- v10 | 0 | 1 | [
66,
88,
24,
86,
68,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
85,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
77,
87,
88,
24,
46... | 147 |
111,059 | 48,614 | policy_missing_premise | Q, v8, (v3 => Q), v5, v24, v22, ((v16 & v22) => v15), v0, v14, v2, (v4 => v12), v18, R, v7, v23, P, v12, v13, S, (v6 => v0), (v21 => v18), v25, (v17 => v7) |- v15 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | Q, v8, (v3 => Q), v5, v24, v22, ((v16 & v22) => v15), v0, v14, v2, (v4 => v12), v18, R, v7, v23, P, v12, v13, S, (v6 => v0), (v21 => v18), v25, (v17 => v7) |- v15 | 0 | 1 | [
67,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
86,
46,
79,
24,
8,
24,
67,
87,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
77,
82,
24,
9,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
1... | 155 |
769 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | L_IMP | 2 | 8 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 0 | 9 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
8... | 206 |
770 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v10, v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | AXIOM | 0 | -100 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 1 | 9 | [
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
8... | 198 |
771 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v18 | L_IMP | 2 | 15 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 2 | 9 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
8... | 193 |
772 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v18, v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v18 | AXIOM | 0 | -100 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 3 | 9 | [
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
8... | 186 |
773 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v6 | L_IMP | 2 | 8 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 4 | 9 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
8... | 180 |
774 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v6, v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v6 | AXIOM | 0 | -100 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 5 | 9 | [
46,
82,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
2... | 164 |
775 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- (v15 & v17) | R_AND | 3 | -100 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 6 | 9 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
8... | 169 |
776 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v15 | AXIOM | 0 | -100 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 7 | 9 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
8... | 161 |
777 | 325 | horn_policy_provable | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v17 | AXIOM | 0 | -100 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v17, v15, (v4 => v0), (v21 => v22), (v7 => v23), v8, v27, v2, (v18 => v10), ((v15 & v17) => v6), v14, (v14 => v12), Q, v5, v0, v20, (v6 => v18), R, v16, v22, v11, v24, v12, v23, v9, P, S, v12, (v26 => v9), v1 |- v10 | 8 | 9 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
12,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
8... | 161 |
142,294 | 97,472 | policy_missing_premise | v6, S, v4, (S => v27), v2, v24, v3, v3, v0, v18, v12, v1, (v17 => v23), (P => v15), v20, v27, v25, v15, v16, v5, (v23 => v7), v10, (v22 => v25), v14, v19, v13, v26, v13, v9, (v0 => v3), (v14 => v13) |- v7 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v6, S, v4, (S => v27), v2, v24, v3, v3, v0, v18, v12, v1, (v17 => v23), (P => v15), v20, v27, v25, v15, v16, v5, (v23 => v7), v10, (v22 => v25), v14, v19, v13, v26, v13, v9, (v0 => v3), (v14 => v13) |- v7 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
82,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
24,
86,
69,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
83,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
... | 196 |
223,760 | 225,063 | constructive_refutation | (v27 => S), ~v19, v8, S |- (v19 & v3) | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v27 => S), ~v19, v8, S |- (v19 & v3) | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
78,
83,
24,
8,
24,
69,
87,
88,
24,
11,
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
46,
84,
88,
24,
69,
24,
5,
24,
86,
46,
77,
85,
24,
9,
24,
46,
79,
87
] | 35 |
210,528 | 204,314 | policy_missing_premise | ((v16 & v22) => v6), v1, v5, v26, v11, v14, v17, v20, v25, (v17 => v20), v21, R, v13, (P => v26), S, (v6 => v23), v7, v0, (v5 => v13), v20, v27, (v23 => v12), v22, (v15 => v11), (v10 => R), Q, v2, v3, v18, v9, v13 |- v12 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ((v16 & v22) => v6), v1, v5, v26, v11, v14, v17, v20, v25, (v17 => v20), v21, R, v13, (P => v26), S, (v6 => v23), v7, v0, (v5 => v13), v20, v27, (v23 => v12), v22, (v15 => v11), (v10 => R), Q, v2, v3, v18, v9, v13 |- v12 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
86,
46,
77,
82,
24,
9,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
82,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
46,
77,
80,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
78,
12,
88,
24,
... | 211 |
156,802 | 120,182 | policy_missing_premise | ((R & v6) => v7), v25, (v14 => v24), v1, (v22 => v13), v13, P, v21, v10, v8, v5, (Q => v10), v6, v9, v22, v27, v26, v16, (v7 => v23), v24, v11, v12, v15, v0, (v18 => v27), v4, (S => P), v3 |- v23 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ((R & v6) => v7), v25, (v14 => v24), v1, (v22 => v13), v13, P, v21, v10, v8, v5, (Q => v10), v6, v9, v22, v27, v26, v16, (v7 => v23), v24, v11, v12, v15, v0, (v18 => v27), v4, (S => P), v3 |- v23 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
86,
68,
24,
9,
24,
46,
82,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
83,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
80,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
79,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77... | 187 |
40 | 21 | policy_refutation_contradiction | P, v26, (v23 => v22), v6, R, v14, (v10 => R), v18, v2, v24, v19, v22, v25, v15, v7, v20, v3, (v5 => ~Q), (v4 => v14), v0, S, v11, (v17 => v24), v9, (v27 => v18), ((v26 & v3) => v5) |- Q | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | P, v26, (v23 => v22), v6, R, v14, (v10 => R), v18, v2, v24, v19, v22, v25, v15, v7, v20, v3, (v5 => ~Q), (v4 => v14), v0, S, v11, (v17 => v24), v9, (v27 => v18), ((v26 & v3) => v5) |- Q | 0 | 1 | [
66,
88,
24,
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
46,
82,
88,
24,
68,
88,
24,
46,
77,
80,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
12,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
... | 177 |
140,658 | 94,910 | policy_missing_premise | v5, v24, v11, v21, (v21 => R), v13, v7, (v20 => v10), v8, (v16 => v22), P, Q, (v14 => v11), R, R, v25, ((v25 & v9) => v23), v12, v6, v11, S, v14, v22, v10, v3, v26, (v1 => v5), v15, v27, (v23 => v18), v0 |- v18 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v5, v24, v11, v21, (v21 => R), v13, v7, (v20 => v10), v8, (v16 => v22), P, Q, (v14 => v11), R, R, v25, ((v25 & v9) => v23), v12, v6, v11, S, v14, v22, v10, v3, v26, (v1 => v5), v15, v27, (v23 => v18), v0 |- v18 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
81,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
46,
78,
77,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
77,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
79,
88,
24,
46,
83,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
12,
87,
88,
24,
46,
... | 202 |
169,538 | 140,154 | constructive_refutation | (v4 => v22), ~v22, (P => v4) |- P | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v4 => v22), ~v22, (P => v4) |- P | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
11,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
86,
66,
24,
8,
24,
46,
80,
87,
24,
5,
24,
66
] | 30 |
124,205 | 69,179 | policy_missing_premise | v13, ((v6 & v13) => R) |- R | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v13, ((v6 & v13) => R) |- R | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
79,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
82,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
79,
87,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
24,
5,
24,
68
] | 25 |
20,709 | 8,358 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v25, v3, v6, v11, v21, v0, v18, v16, v22, v19, v5, (S => P), v13, (v8 => v24), (v7 => v9), v1, v23, R, v9, v24, v2, v4, Q, (v15 => v0), (v17 => v6), v10, P, ((v25 & v1) => ~v20) |- v20 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v25, v3, v6, v11, v21, v0, v18, v16, v22, v19, v5, (S => P), v13, (v8 => v24), (v7 => v9), v1, v23, R, v9, v24, v2, v4, Q, (v15 => v0), (v17 => v6), v10, P, ((v25 & v1) => ~v20) |- v20 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
82,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
46,
78,
77,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
46,
81,
88,
24,
86,
69,
... | 177 |
228,558 | 232,581 | constructive_refutation | ~v2, P, ~v10, (v13 => P), v1 |- (v2 | v10) | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | ~v2, P, ~v10, (v13 => P), v1 |- (v2 | v10) | 0 | 1 | [
11,
46,
78,
88,
24,
66,
88,
24,
11,
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
79,
24,
8,
24,
66,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
24,
5,
24,
86,
46,
78,
24,
10,
24,
46,
77,
12,
87
] | 40 |
119,991 | 62,586 | constructive_refutation | (v18 => v23), (R => v16), ~v3, v16, v18, v23, (v9 => v3), v23, (v16 => v18), R |- v9 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v18 => v23), (R => v16), ~v3, v16, v18, v23, (v9 => v3), v23, (v16 => v18), R |- v9 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
79,
87,
88,
24,
86,
68,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
82,
87,
88,
24,
11,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
79,
88,
24,
86,
46,
85,
24,
8,
24,
46,
79,
87,
8... | 79 |
59,449 | 24,005 | policy_missing_premise | v17, v11, v10, v19, v12, v2, v4, v20, (v6 => v19), P, v0, (v14 => v13), (v25 => v27), (S => P), v23, v3, v8, (v22 => v11), v15, v5, (R => v17), v24, ((v5 & Q) => v25), v13 |- v27 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v17, v11, v10, v19, v12, v2, v4, v20, (v6 => v19), P, v0, (v14 => v13), (v25 => v27), (S => P), v23, v3, v8, (v22 => v11), v15, v5, (R => v17), v24, ((v5 & Q) => v25), v13 |- v27 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
24,
46,
78,
12,
88,
24,
86,
46,
82,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
85,
87,
88,
24,
66,
88,
24,
... | 170 |
222,186 | 222,588 | policy_refutation_contradiction | (v19 => v25), v23, v3, v15, ((v4 & v13) => v17), S, v13, v26, v27, v9, v14, (v1 => v2), v2, v21, (S => v8), v24, v11, R, v22, (S => ~v17), (v12 => v14), v8, v25, v20, (v5 => v20) |- v17 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v19 => v25), v23, v3, v15, ((v4 & v13) => v17), S, v13, v26, v27, v9, v14, (v1 => v2), v2, v21, (S => v8), v24, v11, R, v22, (S => ~v17), (v12 => v14), v8, v25, v20, (v5 => v20) |- v17 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
85,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
79,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
80,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
79,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
83,
87,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
46,
77,
79,
8... | 177 |
194,676 | 179,517 | policy_refutation_contradiction | (v25 => ~v15), (v1 => S), v2, v3, S, ((v2 & v3) => v25) |- v15 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v25 => ~v15), (v1 => S), v2, v3, S, ((v2 & v3) => v25) |- v15 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
78,
81,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
24,
8,
24,
69,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
78,
24,
9,
24,
46,
79,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
81,
87,
24,
5,... | 58 |
112,792 | 51,339 | constructive_refutation | v12, ~v12 |- v9 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v12, ~v12 |- v9 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
11,
46,
77,
78,
24,
5,
24,
46,
85
] | 14 |
212,838 | 207,939 | policy_refutation_contradiction | (S => v2), (v13 => v12), v13, v25, v18, v22, (v3 => v18), v16, v23, v20, v12, v2, v21, R, v24, (P => v27), v7, v11, v8, v1, (v5 => v23), v10, v4, v12, (~v17 => ~v14), v27, ((v17 & v0) => v14), v9, ~v17, v18, v0, v15 |- v14 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (S => v2), (v13 => v12), v13, v25, v18, v22, (v3 => v18), v16, v23, v20, v12, v2, v21, R, v24, (P => v27), v7, v11, v8, v1, (v5 => v23), v10, v4, v12, (~v17 => ~v14), v27, ((v17 & v0) => v14), v9, ~v17, v18, v0, v15 |- v14 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
69,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
78,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
79,
88,
24,
46,
78,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87,
8... | 214 |
210,006 | 203,496 | constructive_refutation | ~v8, v6, v19, v27, v1, (v27 => v1), (v17 => v8), (v19 => v27), v1, (v6 => v19) |- v17 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | ~v8, v6, v19, v27, v1, (v27 => v1), (v17 => v8), (v19 => v27), v1, (v6 => v19) |- v17 | 0 | 1 | [
11,
46,
84,
88,
24,
46,
82,
88,
24,
46,
77,
85,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
83,
24,
8,
24,
46,
84,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
85,
24,
8,
2... | 80 |
212,237 | 206,996 | double_negation_elimination | ~~P |- P | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ~~P |- P | 0 | 1 | [
11,
11,
66,
24,
5,
24,
66
] | 7 |
186,154 | 166,209 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v20, v15, v10, (R => v13), (P => v6), v22, Q, (v15 => ~v0), (v11 => v19), (v16 => v0), v19, v12, v19, (v10 => v25), v5, v11, v12, v24, v17, v6, v18, v23, (v15 => v12), (S => v26), v14, v15, v2, (v26 => v16), v27, v25, v7, v8 |- v0 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v20, v15, v10, (R => v13), (P => v6), v22, Q, (v15 => ~v0), (v11 => v19), (v16 => v0), v19, v12, v19, (v10 => v25), v5, v11, v12, v24, v17, v6, v18, v23, (v15 => v12), (S => v26), v14, v15, v2, (v26 => v16), v27, v25, v7, v8 |- v0 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
81,
88,
24,
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
86,
68,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
79,
87,
88,
24,
86,
66,
24,
8,
24,
46,
82,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
67,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
81,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
1... | 220 |
80,933 | 32,625 | constructive_refutation | S, (S => v22), (v22 => ~v13) |- v13 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | S, (S => v22), (v22 => ~v13) |- v13 | 0 | 1 | [
69,
88,
24,
86,
69,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
78,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
77,
79,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
77,
79
] | 32 |
191,553 | 174,645 | constructive_refutation | v6, ~v6 |- R | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v6, ~v6 |- R | 0 | 1 | [
46,
82,
88,
24,
11,
46,
82,
24,
5,
24,
68
] | 11 |
122,820 | 67,023 | constructive_refutation | (v11 => ~Q), v11 |- Q | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (v11 => ~Q), v11 |- Q | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
77,
24,
8,
24,
11,
67,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
77,
24,
5,
24,
67
] | 19 |
78,107 | 31,475 | open_kripke_countermodel | (v26 => v19) |- (v26 & v26) | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v26 => v19) |- (v26 & v26) | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
78,
82,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
85,
87,
24,
5,
24,
86,
46,
78,
82,
24,
9,
24,
46,
78,
82,
87
] | 25 |
152,585 | 113,592 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v26, v22, v7, v3, (v2 => v7), v6, (v4 => v5), R, v1, v25, ((v6 & v15) => v20), v12, v5, v8, v14, v13, v11, v24, (v17 => v14), v3, P, S, v25, v10, (v20 => ~v21), Q, (v24 => v25), v0, v15, v18, v16, (R => v3) |- v21 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v26, v22, v7, v3, (v2 => v7), v6, (v4 => v5), R, v1, v25, ((v6 & v15) => v20), v12, v5, v8, v14, v13, v11, v24, (v17 => v14), v3, P, S, v25, v10, (v20 => ~v21), Q, (v24 => v25), v0, v15, v18, v16, (R => v3) |- v21 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
46,
83,
88,
24,
46,
79,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
83,
87,
88,
24,
46,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
81,
87,
88,
24,
68,
88,
24,
46,
77,
88,
24,
46,
78,
... | 205 |
232,866 | 239,331 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v9, v6, v4, (v15 => v14), (v5 => v9), ~S, v0, v24, v21, (v26 => R), (v25 => v4), v4, (~S => ~R), v22, (v11 => v8), v25, v18, v3, ((S & v17) => v26), v1, v10, v2, v7, v17, (v20 => v3), v14, v27, v5, v9, v23, v8, P |- R | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v9, v6, v4, (v15 => v14), (v5 => v9), ~S, v0, v24, v21, (v26 => R), (v25 => v4), v4, (~S => ~R), v22, (v11 => v8), v25, v18, v3, ((S & v17) => v26), v1, v10, v2, v7, v17, (v20 => v3), v14, v27, v5, v9, v23, v8, P |- R | 0 | 1 | [
46,
85,
88,
24,
46,
82,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
80,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
85,
87,
88,
24,
11,
69,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
46,
78,
77,
88,
... | 208 |
215,393 | 211,940 | double_negation_elimination | ~~v17 |- v17 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ~~v17 |- v17 | 0 | 1 | [
11,
11,
46,
77,
83,
24,
5,
24,
46,
77,
83
] | 11 |
157,794 | 121,737 | policy_refutation_contradiction | v27, v10, ((v27 & v10) => ~v26) |- v26 | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | v27, v10, ((v27 & v10) => ~v26) |- v26 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
46,
77,
12,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
78,
83,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
12,
87,
24,
8,
24,
11,
46,
78,
82,
87,
24,
5,
24,
46,
78,
82
] | 36 |
197,551 | 184,019 | policy_missing_premise | v24, S, (v8 => v18), v21, v4, (v9 => v7), (v22 => v24), v14, v17, v20, v7, (v23 => S), v5, (v0 => v8), v19, (v26 => v14), (v1 => v4) |- v18 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v24, S, (v8 => v18), v21, v4, (v9 => v7), (v22 => v24), v14, v17, v20, v7, (v23 => S), v5, (v0 => v8), v19, (v26 => v14), (v1 => v4) |- v18 | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
80,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
86,
46,
84,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
77,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
24,
86,
46,
85,
24,
8,
24,
46,
83,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
78,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
80,
87,
88,
24,
4... | 131 |
76,458 | 30,806 | policy_missing_premise | ((v16 & v1) => R), v16, (v0 => v22), (R => v19), (v19 => v21) |- v21 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | ((v16 & v1) => R), v16, (v0 => v22), (R => v19), (v19 => v21) |- v21 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
86,
46,
77,
82,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
87,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
82,
88,
24,
86,
46,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
86,
68,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
85,
87,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
85,
24,
8,
24,
46,... | 63 |
124,042 | 68,915 | open_kripke_countermodel | v24 |- ((v4 | v24) & v26) | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | v24 |- ((v4 | v24) & v26) | 0 | 1 | [
46,
78,
80,
24,
5,
24,
86,
86,
46,
80,
24,
10,
24,
46,
78,
80,
87,
24,
9,
24,
46,
78,
82,
87
] | 24 |
94,530 | 38,089 | horn_policy_provable | v0, v12, v18, (v0 => v2), v2, (v15 => R), v17, v4, v24, v2, (v17 => v11), v27, v14, v5, v7, v21, (v6 => v25), v26, S, (v10 => v7), R, v23, v1, v8, v10, P, (Q => v8), v13, v7, v25, v9, v15 |- v11 | L_IMP | 2 | 10 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v0, v12, v18, (v0 => v2), v2, (v15 => R), v17, v4, v24, v2, (v17 => v11), v27, v14, v5, v7, v21, (v6 => v25), v26, S, (v10 => v7), R, v23, v1, v8, v10, P, (Q => v8), v13, v7, v25, v9, v15 |- v11 | 0 | 3 | [
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
86,
46,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
81,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
... | 187 |
94,531 | 38,089 | horn_policy_provable | v11, v0, v12, v18, (v0 => v2), v2, (v15 => R), v17, v4, v24, v2, v27, v14, v5, v7, v21, (v6 => v25), v26, S, (v10 => v7), R, v23, v1, v8, v10, P, (Q => v8), v13, v7, v25, v9, v15 |- v11 | AXIOM | 0 | -100 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v0, v12, v18, (v0 => v2), v2, (v15 => R), v17, v4, v24, v2, (v17 => v11), v27, v14, v5, v7, v21, (v6 => v25), v26, S, (v10 => v7), R, v23, v1, v8, v10, P, (Q => v8), v13, v7, v25, v9, v15 |- v11 | 1 | 3 | [
46,
77,
77,
88,
24,
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
86,
46,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
81,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
... | 179 |
94,532 | 38,089 | horn_policy_provable | v0, v12, v18, (v0 => v2), v2, (v15 => R), v17, v4, v24, v2, v27, v14, v5, v7, v21, (v6 => v25), v26, S, (v10 => v7), R, v23, v1, v8, v10, P, (Q => v8), v13, v7, v25, v9, v15 |- v17 | AXIOM | 0 | -100 | 2PROVEN_TRUE | 1 | v0, v12, v18, (v0 => v2), v2, (v15 => R), v17, v4, v24, v2, (v17 => v11), v27, v14, v5, v7, v21, (v6 => v25), v26, S, (v10 => v7), R, v23, v1, v8, v10, P, (Q => v8), v13, v7, v25, v9, v15 |- v11 | 2 | 3 | [
46,
12,
88,
24,
46,
77,
78,
88,
24,
46,
77,
84,
88,
24,
86,
46,
12,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
77,
81,
24,
8,
24,
68,
87,
88,
24,
46,
77,
83,
88,
24,
46,
80,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
88,
... | 174 |
130,929 | 79,700 | denying_antecedent | (v14 => v25), ~v14 |- ~v25 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | (v14 => v25), ~v14 |- ~v25 | 0 | 1 | [
86,
46,
77,
80,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
81,
87,
88,
24,
11,
46,
77,
80,
24,
5,
24,
11,
46,
78,
81
] | 24 |
90,037 | 36,308 | policy_missing_premise | R, (v3 => v15), v26, Q, ((v10 & v7) => v4), S, v27, v24, (v25 => Q), v19, v23, (v8 => v19), v14, v18, v16, v1, (v5 => S), v10, v13, v15, v12, v0, v17, (v21 => v16) |- v4 | UNDECIDED | -100 | -100 | 1INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED | 0.5 | R, (v3 => v15), v26, Q, ((v10 & v7) => v4), S, v27, v24, (v25 => Q), v19, v23, (v8 => v19), v14, v18, v16, v1, (v5 => S), v10, v13, v15, v12, v0, v17, (v21 => v16) |- v4 | 0 | 1 | [
68,
88,
24,
86,
46,
79,
24,
8,
24,
46,
77,
81,
87,
88,
24,
46,
78,
82,
88,
24,
67,
88,
24,
86,
86,
46,
77,
12,
24,
9,
24,
46,
83,
87,
24,
8,
24,
46,
80,
87,
88,
24,
69,
88,
24,
46,
78,
83,
88,
24,
46,
78,
80,
8... | 162 |
182,156 | 159,963 | constructive_refutation | ~R, v22, (v25 => v22), v9 |- (R & v18) | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | ~R, v22, (v25 => v22), v9 |- (R & v18) | 0 | 1 | [
11,
68,
88,
24,
46,
78,
78,
88,
24,
86,
46,
78,
81,
24,
8,
24,
46,
78,
78,
87,
88,
24,
46,
85,
24,
5,
24,
86,
68,
24,
9,
24,
46,
77,
84,
87
] | 36 |
175,603 | 149,667 | constructive_refutation | (R => ~P), R |- P | REFUTED | -100 | -100 | 0PROVEN_FALSE | 0 | (R => ~P), R |- P | 0 | 1 | [
86,
68,
24,
8,
24,
11,
66,
87,
88,
24,
68,
24,
5,
24,
66
] | 15 |
Gentzen-Kripke-240K is a large-scale formal dataset of 240,000 certified sequents and derivation steps for training and evaluating neuro-symbolic theorem provers, policy verification models, and typed-decision engines.
It was created to train nanoGentzen-v3 (4.93M parameters), the model tested on LocalLLaMA/typed-decisions (76.75% accuracy) and the official S1MB System-1 benchmark (Score 2.50, outperforming 29 published models up to 7.6B parameters).
240,000172,426PROVEN_TRUE, 1.0): 80,000 samples (33.33%)INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED, 0.5): 80,000 samples (33.33%)PROVEN_FALSE, 0.0): 80,000 samples (33.33%)trajectory_id so sub-steps of the same derivation tree DAG are never divided between splits:train: 215,995 samples (90% of trajectories, 21.3 MB Parquet)validation: 24,005 samples (10% of trajectories, 2.4 MB Parquet)| Field Name | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
sample_id |
int64 |
Globally unique sample identifier (1 to 240,000). |
trajectory_id |
int64 |
Identifier grouping all steps belonging to the same root derivation DAG. |
curriculum |
string |
Task curriculum category (e.g. horn_policy_provable, policy_missing_premise, constructive_refutation, constructive_de_morgan_1, open_kripke_countermodel). |
sequent |
string |
The intuitionistic sequent in ASCII syntax: Ξ β’ Ξ (e.g. `(Q |
rule |
string |
Target Gentzen inference rule name (AXIOM, R_IMP, L_IMP, R_AND, L_AND, R_OR_1, R_OR_2, L_OR, R_NOT, L_NOT, L_CONTR, or NONE). |
rule_idx |
int64 |
Integer rule index (0 to 10 for Gentzen rules, -100 for unprovable/refuted steps). |
pivot |
int64 |
Target antecedent index in (\Gamma) ((0 \dots 31)) to apply the left-rule on; -100 for right rules and axioms. |
target_epistemic |
class_label |
0 = PROVEN_FALSE, 1 = INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED, 2 = PROVEN_TRUE. |
target_value |
float64 |
Normalized continuous target value: 0.0, 0.5, or 1.0. |
root_sequent |
string |
The root sequent from which this derivation step originated. |
trace_step |
int64 |
Zero-indexed step index in the backward derivation. |
total_trace_steps |
int64 |
Total number of steps in the verified proof trace. |
input_ids |
list<int64> |
Pre-tokenized token sequence using the official nanoGentzen 95-token logic vocabulary. |
token_length |
int64 |
Length of the tokenized sequence (max 256). |
| Split | Number of Examples | Epistemic Balance (False / Undecided / True) |
Parquet Size |
|---|---|---|---|
train |
215,995 |
71,879 / 71,873 / 72,243 |
21.31 MB |
validation |
24,005 |
8,121 / 8,127 / 7,757 |
2.42 MB |
| Total | 240,000 |
80,000 / 80,000 / 80,000 |
23.72 MB |
datasets
from datasets import load_dataset
# Load directly from Hugging Face Hub
dataset = load_dataset("Sagicc/gentzen-kripke-240k")
# Access train and validation splits
train_data = dataset["train"]
val_data = dataset["validation"]
# Inspect a sample
print(train_data[0])
# {
# 'sample_id': 1,
# 'trajectory_id': 1,
# 'curriculum': 'constructive_disjunctive_cases',
# 'sequent': '(Q | v19), (Q => v4), (v19 => v4) |- v4',
# 'rule': 'L_OR',
# 'rule_idx': 7,
# 'pivot': 0,
# 'target_epistemic': 2,
# 'target_value': 1.0,
# ...
# }
pandas or pyarrow
import pandas as pd
train_df = pd.read_parquet("train.parquet")
val_df = pd.read_parquet("validation.parquet")
print(f"Loaded {len(train_df):,} training sequents across {train_df['curriculum'].nunique()} curricula.")
.pt)
import torch
# Load full dataset samples list
samples = torch.load("gentzen_dataset.pt", map_location="cpu", weights_only=False)
print(f"Loaded {len(samples):,} PyTorch tensor samples.")
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
β Gentzen-Kripke-240K (240,000 Samples) β
ββββββββββββββββββββββββ¬ββββββββββββββββββββββββ
β
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββΌββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
β (33.3%) β (33.3%) β (33.3%)
βΌ βΌ βΌ
ββββββββββββββββββββ ββββββββββββββββββββ ββββββββββββββββββββ
β Class 2 β β Class 1 β β Class 0 β
β PROVEN_TRUE β β UNDETERMINED β β PROVEN_FALSE β
β 80,000 Samples β β 80,000 Samples β β 80,000 Samples β
ββββββββββ¬ββββββββββ ββββββββββ¬ββββββββββ ββββββββββ¬ββββββββββ
β β β
ββ Multi-Hop Horn (47.2k) ββ Premise Deprived (44.0k) ββ Policy Violations (40.1k)
ββ De Morgan Laws (9.7k) ββ Kripke Countermodels (14.4k) ββ Refutations (39.9k)
ββ Disjunctive Cases (4.7k) ββ Classical LEM / Peirce (11.0k)ββ Modus Tollens Chains
ββ Refutation Proofs (4.5k) ββ Affirming Consequent (10.6k)
PROVEN_TRUE, 80,000 samples):
Constructively derived theorems in Gerhard Gentzen's (\mathbf{LJ}) sequent calculus. Each step provides the exact invertible or non-invertible Gentzen inference rule (rule) and antecedent pivot index (pivot). Includes multi-hop Horn policies (1 to 3 hops), De Morgan dualities, double negation of excluded middle (\neg\neg(P \lor \neg P)), and conjunction/disjunction distribution.INTUITIONISTIC_UNDECIDED, 80,000 samples):
Underdetermined sequents lacking sufficient constructive evidence. Includes policies missing critical prerequisite facts, classical fallacies that fail intuitionistically (Law of Excluded Middle, Peirce's Law, Double Negation Elimination), and open Kripke tableaus.PROVEN_FALSE, 80,000 samples):
Constructive refutations and contradictions. Sequents where the antecedent premises (\Gamma) derive (\neg G) or (\Gamma, G \vdash \bot), representing policy violations, contradictory constraints, and Modus Tollens refutation chains.Unlike standard sequence-to-sequence provers, Gentzen-Kripke-240K supervises a Span Pointer Antecedent Pivot Attention Head:
Sagicc/nanoGentzen-v3 (4.93M parameters, 19.6 MB weights)https://github.com/nanoGentzen-v3_train)This dataset is released under the MIT License.