Datasets:
id stringlengths 34 34 | text stringlengths 849 10.8k | family stringclasses 1
value | kind stringclasses 3
values | source stringclasses 141
values | court stringclasses 141
values | gold stringlengths 561 1.29k | presentation stringclasses 3
values | group_id stringlengths 33 40 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
cap_outcome_chain-2e53d06c176ca121 | This is an excerpt from a court's decision on appeal. Answer the question that follows. The answer should reflect the decision of the court that wrote the main opinion.
Text:
(51 Misc. 669)
FRIED v. WELLS FARGO & CO.
(Supreme Court, Appellate Term.
November 14, 1906.)
Gabblers of Goods—Limitation of Liability—Notice o... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nys | New York Supreme Court, Appellate Term | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment will be reversed, and a new trial ordered, with costs to appellant to abide the event.", "dissent"... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:5559486|7689863 |
cap_outcome_chain-8acfb4e81ec4a8bc | Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below. Keep the answer short.
Passage:
DEITCH et al. v. FEDER et al.
(Supreme Court, Appellate Term.
February 23, 1904.)
1. Conflicting Evidence—Vebdict—Conclusiveness.
A verdict on conflicting evidence will not be reversed where there is not such a clear preponder... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_disp | cap:nys | New York Supreme Court, Appellate Term | {"anchor_kind": "oc_disp", "anchor_answer": "affirmed", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Judgment affirmed, with costs. All concur.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_op... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:5559486|7689863 |
cap_outcome_chain-39445fb3a9f4c733 | The following passage is taken from a published appellate decision. Answer the question that comes after it. Rely only on the passage.
Answer the following questions.
1. Was the appeal taken by the plaintiff or by the defendant?
2. Taking into account who appealed and how the court ruled, which side came out ahead on ... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:f2d | United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence+caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "AFFIRMED.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "histo... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:714919|1423355 |
cap_outcome_chain-a047dc6a63fcdb59 | <|start|><|user|>
Answer using the case text that follows.
Excerpt:
(No. 34136.
The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, Appellant, vs. Justin T. McCarthy, Director of Insurance, et al., Appellees.
Opinion filed January 24, 1957
Rehearing denied March 19, 1957.
CrydE J. Cover, of Fort Wayne, Indiana, and GirrespiE... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:ill-2d | Illinois Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Decree affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "histor... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:2775135|2724941 |
cap_outcome_chain-4045139804fcaebc | <|start|><|system|>
You are a careful assistant. Follow the user's instructions exactly.<|eot|>
<|user|>
Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below.
Who prevailed in this court, the plaintiff or the defendant?
<text>
(No. 34674.
Leda Boudreau Yeates, Appellant, vs. Genevieve Daily et al., Appellees.
... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:ill-2d | Illinois Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and remanded, with directions.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_op... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:2775135|2724941 |
cap_outcome_chain-92bdbc6c95229cd0 | <|start|><|user|>
Case excerpt follows. Read it, then answer the question. Do not use outside knowledge of the case.
```
GABE KAIMOWITZ v. DUKE LAW JOURNAL
No. 8314SC788
(Filed 15 May 1984)
Contracts § 27.1— existence and breach of contract — genuine issues of material fact
The evidence on motion for summary judgment ... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nc-app | North Carolina Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and remanded.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:8527410|8522490 |
cap_outcome_chain-7e8b409d6e3e8ef8 | Use the opinion excerpt to answer the question. Base the answer only on what the excerpt says.
<text>
PRUE W. MARTIN v. MITCHELL ALLEN MARTIN and KATHY MARTIN
No. 8427SC498
(Filed 19 February 1985)
Trusts 8 19— constructive trust — no evidence of misrepresentation —summary judgment for defendant proper
Summary judgmen... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nc-app | North Carolina Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem"... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:8527410|8522490 |
cap_outcome_chain-055be610b8b7e974 | ### Task
Use the opinion excerpt to answer the question. Base the answer only on what the excerpt says.
Questions:
1. Is the appealing party the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. On this appeal, which party prevailed, the plaintiff or the defendant?
Excerpt:
BODIN APPAREL, INC., et al., Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Michael... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:sw2d | Tennessee Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "AFFIRMED.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem":... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:9964335|9973656 |
cap_outcome_chain-0476a4bef37b945c | Question: Answer the question about how this appeal came out, using only the text provided. Keep the answer short.
Passage:
Ronnie H. GAMBILL, Individually and as next friend for Holly Gambill, a minor, and on Behalf of Amanda Morciz, a minor, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. MIDDLE TENNESSEE MEDICAL CENTER, INC., and Timoth... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:sw2d | Tennessee Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and remanded.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "h... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:9964335|9973656 |
cap_outcome_chain-6f49733c88fbfccd | From the court record below, determine the answer. Rely only on the passage.
Answer the following questions.
1. Which party appealed, the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. Who prevailed in this court, the plaintiff or the defendant?
Text:
STATE OF MONTANA, Plaintiff and Respondent, v. KATHLEEN FAY SCHINDLER, Defendant a... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:mont | Montana Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem":... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:4560022|2683418 |
cap_outcome_chain-2b6aa358cb7b6279 | Task: Below are excerpts from a reported case: the head matter, parts of the court's opinion and, where there is one, part of a separate opinion. Answer the question. The answer should reflect the decision of the court that wrote the main opinion.
Which party appealed, the plaintiff or the defendant?
```
MICHAEL WEST... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:mont | Montana Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem":... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:4560022|2683418 |
cap_outcome_chain-9bd54bb188c4ff40 | <|start|><|user|>
The following passage is taken from a published appellate decision. Answer the question that comes after it.
"""
CONTRACT MATERIALS COMPANY, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. OAHE LAND AND CATTLE CO., INC., a Corporation; Elwin Pearey; and G.E. Kelso, Defendants, and Morris Irrigation, Inc., A Corporation;... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nw2d | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment is affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "h... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10678019|10632768 |
cap_outcome_chain-b1ddeb20f7b04549 | Request: Use the opinion excerpt to answer the question. Base the answer only on what the excerpt says. Keep the answer short.
"""
Wayne THORMODSGARD, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. WAYNE TOWNSHIP BOARD OF SUPERVISORS, Harry Groshart, Roland Hagen and Erwin Edeler, Minnehaha County, South Dakota, Defendants and Appellees... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nw2d | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment is reversed, and the ease is remanded to the trial court for entry of an appropriate judgment.", "diss... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10678019|10632768 |
cap_outcome_chain-5b77b375e4a23a23 | <|start|><|user|>
Case excerpt follows. Read it, then answer the question.
Passage:
Willis LANGLEY, Jr., Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Carrie Kingrey LANGLEY, Defendant-Appellee.
No. 85-1226.
Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.
Nov. 5, 1986.
Guillory, McGee and Mayeux, A. Frank McGee, and A. Gerard Caswell, Eunice,... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:so2d | Louisiana Court of Appeal | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "AFFIRMED.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem": tr... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:7645442|7579301 |
cap_outcome_chain-a915df7431581e2a | Question: Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below.
Passage:
Delores M. MACK v. WINN DIXIE OF LOUISIANA, INC., et al.
No. 83CA0223.
Court of Appeal of Louisiana, First Circuit.
Nov. 22, 1983.
Larry P. Boudreaux, Thibodaux, for plaintiff-appellee Delores M. Mack.
Stephen D. Ridley of McCalla, Thompso... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:so2d | Louisiana Court of Appeal | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "REVERSED AND RENDERED.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:7645442|7579301 |
cap_outcome_chain-caab19094d57ed51 | Task: Use the opinion excerpt to answer the question. Base the answer only on what the excerpt says.
Passage:
William J. JANICKE, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Betty HOUGH, Defendant-Respondent.
No. 24330.
Kansas City Court of Appeals. Missouri.
Feb. 7, 1966.
John J. Phillips and James S. Cotting-ham, Independence, for appe... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:sw2d | Kansas City Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": "defendant", "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment is reversed and the cause is remanded.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail"... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10138436|10165010 |
cap_outcome_chain-2421db8fd4293536 | [Task]
Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below.
"""
Stella Ann KEEFER, Appellant, v. Clarence S. HARTZLER, Respondent.
No. 23375.
Kansas City Court of Appeals. Missouri.
Nov. 6, 1961.
Felix V. Gross, Pleasant Hill, E. J. Murphy, Butler, John C. Milholland, Harrison-ville, for appellant.
Ray L. Shub... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:sw2d | Kansas City Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": "defendant", "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Therefore, the judgment is affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "f... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10138436|10165010 |
cap_outcome_chain-5896920b2b5412f9 | Using the excerpt of the opinion, answer the question about the parties and the result. Keep the answer short.
Excerpt:
MATCHETT v. LIEBIG.
Evidence, on a motion to set aside a default judgment, on the ground that it was void because defendant had not been served with summons, the motion therefore not being addressed ... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:sd | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "hm+closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": "Reversed.", "closing_para": "The order of the circuit court is reversed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail":... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:8589213|8516968 |
cap_outcome_chain-9c3ee697da9a06f8 | <|start|><|user|>
Using the excerpt of the opinion, answer the question about the parties and the result. Rely only on the passage.
Text:
STINE v. FOSTER.
In replevin to recov.er certain torses delivered to plaintiff pursuant to an exchange, and retaken by defendant under an alleged agreement to reitrade if not satisf... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:sd | South Dakota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": "defendant", "gsrc": "hm+closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": "Affirmed.", "closing_para": "This case seems to have been very fully and fairly submitted to the jury, and, finding no erro... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:8589213|8516968 |
cap_outcome_chain-4bf35bc2dbd1f5e0 | Read this reported decision (excerpted) and answer briefly. Note that dissenting opinions do not decide the case.
Did the plaintiff or the defendant win the appeal?
Passage:
NATIONAL ADVERTISING COMPANY, a Delaware Corporation, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. The DEPARTMENT OF HIGHWAYS of the State of Colorado, State of Color... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:p2d | Colorado Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment of the district court is reversed, and the case remanded for entry of judgment consistent with this op... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10415317|10432919 |
cap_outcome_chain-7b580db6fb3731a0 | Task: Use the opinion excerpt to answer the question. Base the answer only on what the excerpt says.
```
HALLMARK BUILDERS AND REALTY, a Colorado corporation, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. CITY OF GUNNISON, a Municipal corporation, Defendant-Appellant.
No. 81SA319.
Supreme Court of Colorado, En Banc.
Sept. 7, 1982.
Ranous & ... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:p2d | Colorado Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "We affirm the judgment of the district court.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": true, "fn_o... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10415317|10432919 |
cap_outcome_chain-4424a42412df3bad | <|start|><|user|>
Use the opinion excerpt to answer the question. Base the answer only on what the excerpt says. Note that dissenting opinions do not decide the case.
Was the appeal taken by the plaintiff or by the defendant?
Text:
STATE of Missouri, Plaintiff-Respondent, v. Darel MAXON, Defendant-Appellant.
No. 2230... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:sw3d | Missouri Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence+caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment is affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_oppos... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10018579|11552440 |
cap_outcome_chain-5ab90ff7bb35027b | Read this reported decision (excerpted) and answer briefly.
Questions:
1. Was the appeal taken by the plaintiff or by the defendant?
2. On this appeal, which party prevailed, the plaintiff or the defendant?
"""
STATE of Missouri, Plaintiff-Respondent, v. Timothy John HUCKIN, Defendant Appellant.
No. 17996.
Missouri C... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:sw2d | Missouri Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence+caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment is reversed and the cause remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10018579|11552440 |
cap_outcome_chain-693cad608659bfc5 | Read this reported decision (excerpted) and answer briefly.
```
STATE OF NEW JERSEY, PLAINTIFF-RESPONDENT, v. KENNETH BURKE, DEFENDANT-APPELLANT.
Superior Court of New Jersey Appellate Division
Argued February 25, 1980
Decided March 18, 1980.
Before Judges ALLCORN, MORGAN and FRANCIS.
G. Dolph Corradino argued the cau... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nj-super | New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem": fa... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:293156|287886 |
cap_outcome_chain-53129e90027d1055 | Request: Look at the opinion text and answer. Parts of the opinion have been omitted where marked. Note that dissenting opinions do not decide the case.
Passage:
STATE OF NEW JERSEY, PLAINTIFF-RESPONDENT, v. WILLIE L. CRUDUP, DEFENDANT-APPELLANT.
Superior Court of New Jersey Appellate Division
Argued September 16, 198... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nj-super | New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and remanded.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "hist... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:293156|287886 |
cap_outcome_chain-a8982c585d58fe2b | The following passage is taken from a published appellate decision. Answer the question that comes after it. The answer should reflect the decision of the court that wrote the main opinion.
```
FARMERS NEW WORLD LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. BOUNTIFUL CITY; McNeil Construction; Sharp, Sorensen an... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:p2d | Utah Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The trial court’s order of summary judgment on the contract claims is reversed, and this case is remanded for a ... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10384810|10322420 |
cap_outcome_chain-0bbb9b38d752d216 | <|start|><|user|>
Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below. Do not use outside knowledge of the case.
Example 1
Text:
UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. Howard Stanton LEWIS, Defendant-Appellant.
No. 91-10280.
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit.
Submitted Sept. 16, 1992 .
D... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:p2d | Utah Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence+caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "We therefore affirm the summary judgment.", "dissent": true, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": f... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10384810|10322420 |
cap_outcome_chain-dd3c42799f9b72c9 | Request: Case excerpt follows. Read it, then answer the question.
Passage:
James Lee NEAVILL, Jr., by James Lee Neavill, Sr., his Next Friend, Appellant, v. Myrtle H. KLEMP, Respondent.
No. 53057.
Supreme Court of Missouri, Division No. 1.
May 13, 1968.
Robert A. Mcllrath, Flat River, for appellant.
Roberts & Roberts,... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:sw2d | Supreme Court of Missouri | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": "defendant", "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Judgment affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": fa... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10177798|10131594 |
cap_outcome_chain-fa89275dbc92843f | <|start|><|user|>
Answer the question about how this appeal came out, using only the text provided. Answer for the court's own decision, not for a separate opinion or an earlier court.
```
STATE of Missouri ex rel. STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION of Missouri, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. G. A. BROCKFELD et al., Exceptions to the ... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:sw2d | Supreme Court of Missouri | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment is reversed and the cause remanded.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10177798|10131594 |
cap_outcome_chain-150bd995de66a7ff | Q: Below are excerpts from a reported case: the head matter, parts of the court's opinion and, where there is one, part of a separate opinion. Answer the question.
Excerpt:
UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. Jane DOE (R.S.W.), Defendant-Appellant.
No. 97-30042.
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circu... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:f3d | United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "AFFIRMED.", "dissent": true, "dissent_opposite": true, "fn_tail": true, "fn_opposite": true, "history_stem": true, ... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:7413886|1235823 |
cap_outcome_chain-4f755116658c873d | Q: Below are excerpts from a reported case: the head matter, parts of the court's opinion and, where there is one, part of a separate opinion. Answer the question. Rely only on the passage.
Answer these in order.
1. Who appealed to this court, the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. Which side does the result in this court... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:f3d | United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "REVERSED and REMANDED for a new trial.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_oppo... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:7413886|1235823 |
cap_outcome_chain-83b567be5d4a4f8b | Answer using the case text that follows.
Is the appealing party the plaintiff or the defendant?
Passage:
GOLDEN RULE INSURANCE COMPANY, An Illinois Corporation, Appellant-Plaintiff, v. Sally McCARTY, Commissioner of Insurance, Indiana Department of Insurance, State of Indiana, Appellees-Defendants.
No. 49A02-0010-CV-... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:ne2d | Court of Appeals of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "For all of these reasons, the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": f... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:8440935|9495389 |
cap_outcome_chain-e13d9d81ea67f0d4 | Request: Read this reported decision (excerpted) and answer briefly.
Answer these in order.
1. Is the appealing party the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. Which party won this appeal, the plaintiff or the defendant?
```
STATE of Indiana, Appellant-Plaintiff, v. Quentin FRIDY, Appellee-Defendant.
No. 65A01-0509-CR-418.
... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:ne2d | Court of Appeals of Indiana | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and remanded.", "dissent": true, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "hi... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:8440935|9495389 |
cap_outcome_chain-f9f06ba733e28e07 | Task: Case excerpt follows. Read it, then answer the question. Note that dissenting opinions do not decide the case.
Answer each question.
1. Who appealed to this court, the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. Which side does the result in this court favor, the plaintiff or the defendant?
Passage:
JOHNSON v. SOUTHERN RAIL... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:sc | Supreme Court of South Carolina | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "hm+closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": "Affirmed.", "closing_para": "The judgment of the Circuit Court is affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tai... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:4424259|4425402 |
cap_outcome_chain-b1e97d4a2b89a046 | Read this reported decision (excerpted) and answer briefly. Answer for the court's own decision, not for a separate opinion or an earlier court.
---
BLOWERS v. SOUTHERN RY.
Evidence — Nonsuit—Quantum Meruit. — Incompetent evidence admitted without objection becomes competent, and on motion of nonsuit the sufficiency o... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:sc | Supreme Court of South Carolina | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "hm+closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": "Reversed.", "closing_para": "It is the judgment oí this Court, that the judgment oí the Circuit Court be reversed and the case rem... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:4424259|4425402 |
cap_outcome_chain-176f1f9d8523b6f1 | Query: Read the court opinion excerpt below and answer the question about the appeal.
"""
RAPIDES CREDIT MEN’S ASSOCIATION v. W. R. CORE.
No. 4781.
Court of Appeal of Louisiana. First Circuit.
March 23, 1959.
Rehearing Denied April 27, 1959.
Shapiro & Shapiro, Alexandria, Horace R. Alexius, Jr., Covington, for appella... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:so2d | Louisiana Court of Appeal | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment is affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": fa... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:9899766|9898118 |
cap_outcome_chain-cd64ae86bc9c9824 | <|start|><|user|>
Consider the case excerpt and respond to the question below.
Answer these in order.
1. Which party appealed, the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. What did the court do with the judgment appealed from, affirm it or reverse it?
"""
Roy Lee BORDERS, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. LUMBERMENS MUTUAL CASUALTY CO.,... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:so2d | Louisiana Court of Appeal | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and rendered.", "dissent": true, "dissent_opposite": true, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "his... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:9899766|9898118 |
cap_outcome_chain-94d5a467ae37f0bd | <|start|><|user|>
Answer using the case text that follows.
Excerpt:
Wanda KRUPSKI, a single person, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. COSTA CRUISE LINES, N.V., LLC, d.b.a. Costa Cruise Lines, a foreign corporation (Netherland Antilles), Defendant, Costa Crociere, SPA, a foreign corporation (Italy), Defendant-Appellee.
No. 08-16... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:f-appx | United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "REVERSED AND REMANDED.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "h... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:5727506|4200137 |
cap_outcome_chain-36e132e15165b923 | <|start|><|system|>
Answer accurately and concisely.<|eot|>
<|user|>
Answer using the case text that follows.
"""
Louis CASTRO, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. DIRECTOR, FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Defendants-Appellees.
No. 11-12172
Non-Argument Calendar.
United States Court o... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:f-appx | United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "AFFIRMED.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem":... | chat | cap_outcome_chain|pair:5727506|4200137 |
cap_outcome_chain-c20c64dee37cbba2 | Task: Here is part of an appellate opinion. Work out the answer from the text.
Answer these in order.
1. Who brought this appeal: the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. Who prevailed in this court, the plaintiff or the defendant?
```
Barbara BAILEY, a minor, By her father and natural guardian, James E. BAILEY, Appellant,... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:nw2d | Minnesota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment of the trial court is affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10682964|10677655 |
cap_outcome_chain-3ecd881c2c6a8673 | Task: Use the opinion excerpt to answer the question. Base the answer only on what the excerpt says.
Example 1
Text:
Olga FREDRICKSON, by her Attorney, Harold T. Fredrickson, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. BURLEIGH COUNTY, North Dakota, a Municipal Corporation, Groes Broste, Chairman, and R. C. Nelson, Jacob Swenson, E.... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_appellant | cap:nw2d | Minnesota Supreme Court | {"anchor_kind": "oc_appellant", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and remanded.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:10682964|10677655 |
cap_outcome_chain-adc99b87bca39155 | Answer using the case text that follows. Keep the answer short.
Which party won this appeal, the plaintiff or the defendant?
Excerpt:
VANN DALE HARGETT, CECIL GLENN HARGETT, GERALD KEITH HARGETT, and FRANCES HARGETT DEASON, Plaintiffs-Appellants v. ROBERT L. HOLLAND, Defendant-Appellee
No. 9220SC589
(Filed 20 July 19... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nc-app | North Carolina Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and remanded.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "hist... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:8521144|11202431 |
cap_outcome_chain-a2d4214b2c15d0f6 | [Task]
This is an excerpt from a court's decision on appeal. Answer the question that follows. Rely only on the passage.
Text:
STEPHEN ALWART and PHYLLIS ALWART, Plaintiffs-Appellants v. STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY COMPANY, Defendant-Appellee
No.COA98-38
(Filed 1 December 1998)
Insurance— coverage — synthetic stucco ... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:nc-app | North Carolina Court of Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem": fa... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:8521144|11202431 |
cap_outcome_chain-8f4cb9088b93140f | Query: Read the court opinion excerpt below and answer the question about the appeal.
Answer these in order.
1. Who appealed to this court, the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. Did this court affirm or reverse the decision under review?
---
Vivian R. TREVIZO, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Nancy A. BERRYHILL, Acting Commissio... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_disp | cap:f3d | United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | {"anchor_kind": "oc_disp", "anchor_answer": "reversed", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "REVERSED; REMANDED WITH INSTRUCTIONS.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": true, "fn_opposite": t... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:12276024|3515731 |
cap_outcome_chain-569d4d00731df431 | This is an excerpt from a court's decision on appeal. Answer the question that follows.
Passage:
Jose REYNOSO, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. UNITED STATES of America, Defendant-Appellee.
No. 11-15181.
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit.
Argued and Submitted May 14, 2012.
Filed Aug. 28, 2012.
Paul Ham, Esq., San F... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:f3d | United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "plaintiff", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "caption", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "AFFIRMED.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "history_stem": tr... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:12276024|3515731 |
cap_outcome_chain-6df952bc26345cf1 | Instruction: Answer using the case text that follows. Answer for the court's own decision, not for a separate opinion or an earlier court.
Answer these in order.
1. Who brought this appeal: the plaintiff or the defendant?
2. Did the plaintiff or the defendant win the appeal?
<text>
Jack S. COLE, Appellant, v. Stella ... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:sw2d | Texas Courts of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "defendant", "label": "reversed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "Reversed and remanded.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "fn_opposite": false, "... | qa | cap_outcome_chain|pair:9981348|9961783 |
cap_outcome_chain-d51f6e26e18f0d56 | Look at the opinion text and answer. Parts of the opinion have been omitted where marked.
Did the plaintiff or the defendant win the appeal?
```
Lillian M. JUNKERMANN, Appellant, v. J. W. CARRUTH, Appellee.
No. 1787.
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, Corpus Christi.
June 30, 1981.
Andrew D. Leonie, III, McAllen, Charl... | cap_outcome_chain | oc_winner | cap:sw2d | Texas Courts of Civil Appeals | {"anchor_kind": "oc_winner", "anchor_answer": "plaintiff", "label": "affirmed", "appellant": "defendant", "winner_below": null, "gsrc": "closing", "asrc": "hm_sentence", "removed_line": null, "closing_para": "The judgment of the trial court is affirmed.", "dissent": false, "dissent_opposite": false, "fn_tail": false, "... | plain | cap_outcome_chain|pair:9981348|9961783 |
ALEA CAP Outcome Chain
Short reading questions about how an appeal came out, asked over excerpts of published American appellate decisions. Each document gives the head matter of a reported case and parts of the court's opinion, and asks one to three of these questions:
- Who appealed? The plaintiff or the defendant.
- How did this court rule? Affirmed or reversed.
- Who won the appeal? The plaintiff or the defendant.
"Who won the appeal" is a defined two-step chain. If the decision below is reversed, the appellant wins the appeal; if it is affirmed, the other side wins. The answer is about the appeal itself: a reversal counts as a win for the appellant even when the case is sent back for further proceedings.
Answers are short ("The defendant.", "Reversed.") or one plain sentence. They never copy the passage back.
Releases
| release | file | documents | tokens | what is new |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| v1 | data/train-00000-of-00001.parquet |
25,546 | 15.4M | first release |
| v2 | data/train-v2-00000-of-00001.parquet |
8,708 | 5.2M | new documents from cases that v1 did not use |
| total | data/train-*.parquet (the train split loads both files) |
34,254 | 20.6M |
v2 uses the same code, rules, filters and review process as v1, applied to the same scan of the case collection, and only
cases that v1 did not use. Excluded are every case in a v1 pair or used as a v1 worked example (including candidates later
screened out), the same opinion printed in a second reporter (same court, date and name), and any case whose passage
overlaps a v1 document. The v1 file is unchanged (git tags v1 and v2 mark the two releases). v2 is smaller because v1
already used most of the eligible pairs. The pairs that remain are concentrated in a few large courts and in the Federal
Reporter, Second Series, so the same per-court and per-reporter caps as in v1 bind early. v2 also adds one filter, described under "What was left out".
Source
The passages come from the Caselaw Access Project opinions in the KL3M public-record case-law collection (court decisions are public record). Each passage is assembled from whole verbatim pieces of one case, in printed order:
- the head matter;
- the opening paragraphs of the majority opinion;
- the closing paragraphs of the majority opinion;
- in some documents, footnotes printed after the disposition, or the opening and closing of a dissenting opinion.
A line [...] marks omitted text. When the head matter carries a stand-alone disposition line ("Affirmed."), that whole line is
left out, because it is the thing being asked. Otherwise the text is exactly as published in the source collection. That
includes its occasional gaps where the original printing used italics, for example "are the in this suit, which, though the
named is the head of …".
How the answers were derived
All answers are deterministic. No language model was used to write or judge any answer.
Disposition. The disposition is taken from the majority opinion's closing disposition paragraph. That paragraph must:
- contain exactly one of "affirm" or "reverse";
- not contain "in part", "modified", "vacated", "dismissed" or a negation;
- be immediately followed only by footnotes, judges' lines or the end of the opinion.
Where the head matter also prints a stand-alone disposition line, the two must agree.
Appellant. The appellant is the single role named in sentences such as "plaintiff appealed" in the shown text, or the role words in the caption ("Plaintiff-Appellant v. Defendant-Appellee"). When both sources are present they must agree.
Hard negatives for the disposition question. "Affirmed or reversed" is asked only on passages where the first or the last disposition word in the passage is not the court's answer. Examples:
- a dissent that says "I would affirm";
- a footnote reporting another court's reversal;
- a history statement that an intermediate court affirmed.
"Affirmative" and "reversible" are not counted as disposition words.
What was left out
These cases are dropped:
- cross-appeals, answered appeals, and co-party appeals;
- captions with appellants on both sides or the same party on both sides;
- probate and in-re captions;
- appeal sentences whose subject names parties from both sides;
- head matter carrying West key-number notes;
- low OCR confidence (below 0.6) and letter-spaced text.
Criminal cases. Prosecutions (State, People, Commonwealth, United States) are asked who appealed or who won only when the shown caption itself gives the prosecution a plaintiff role word. Otherwise they are asked only the affirmed-or-reversed question, and only as a hard negative.
Partial wins. "Who won the appeal" documents are dropped when the reversal gives directions to enter a particular judgment or conviction, or reduces or modifies an award. That removed 617 documents in v1 and 268 in v2.
Conflicting appellant statements (v2). A who-appealed or who-won document is dropped when any appellant statement in the shown text names a different side from the answer. This covers the caption role words, "Appeal ... by plaintiff" lines and every "defendant appealed" sentence, not only the first one found. It removed 64 v2 documents.
Earlier datasets. Cases already used by earlier ALEA case-law datasets were excluded, including the same opinion printed in a second reporter. v2 also excludes every case used in v1 (see Releases).
Composition
| v1 | v2 | |
|---|---|---|
| documents | 25,546 | 8,708 |
| tokens (alea-v2b-sw32k, with document boundary tokens) | 15,416,762 | 5,198,651 |
| presentations | plain 40%, question-answer frame 30%, chat 30% | plain 41%, question-answer frame 30%, chat 29% |
| questions per document | one (56%) or two to three | one (56%) or two to three |
| demonstrations | about 3% of documents | about 2% of documents |
| question types (anchor) | who won 57%, who appealed 36%, affirmed or reversed 7% | who won 61%, who appealed 37%, affirmed or reversed 2% |
| answer balance | appellant 50/50; who won 50/50; affirmed/reversed 47/53 | appellant 50/50; who won 51/49; affirmed/reversed 55/45 |
| largest court | 4.8%; no court above 5% | 4.9%; no court above 5% |
| largest reporter | about 10% | 9.6% |
| pre-1950 cases | about 12% | about 38% |
Paired documents share a group_id. A pair is one affirmed and one reversed case with the same appellant role, from the same
court and decade, asked with the same wording.
Question-only baselines. v1 / v2:
| question type | prior | baseline accuracy |
|---|---|---|
| who appealed | 0.51 / 0.51 | 0.51 / 0.53–0.54 |
| affirmed or reversed | 0.50 / 0.50 | 0.48–0.50 / 0.45–0.50 |
| who won | 0.50 / 0.52 | 0.49–0.50 / 0.49–0.51 |
In v2, the "who appealed" figure is the share of the majority answer per question wording. The wording is drawn independently of the answer, so the 3-point lift is sampling spread over 1,755 single-question documents. A bag-of-words model over the instruction and question scores 0.50.
Position-only baselines. Copying the last disposition word in the passage answers the affirmed-or-reversed question 46% (v1) / 43% (v2) of the time, and the first one 52% / 54%. The last word alone answers 2.4% (v1) / 0.6% (v2) of all questions.
Columns
| column | content |
|---|---|
id |
row identifier |
text |
the full rendered training document |
family |
cap_outcome_chain |
kind |
the anchor question type: oc_winner, oc_appellant or oc_disp |
source |
cap:<reporter> |
court |
the deciding court |
gold |
JSON string: the disposition, appellant, stated winner below if any, the source of each answer, and per-question answers |
presentation |
plain, qa or chat |
group_id |
shared by paired documents |
Decontamination
Rows were screened with word n-gram rules against evaluation benchmarks, evaluation probes and held-out sets of related datasets. Only real item or passage overlap was dropped (about 7% of candidate rows in v1, 10% in v2, where the screens also cover the v1 release); overlaps limited to legal boilerplate were kept.
Review
Each round had rendered documents checked by hand against their passages, and 60 randomly drawn documents read by an independent blind reviewer.
First round: 1 of 60 wrong. The error was a co-party appeal. The in-house read also found:
- criminal cases answered "the plaintiff" where no plaintiff role is printed;
- copying the last disposition word answered most affirmed-or-reversed questions.
Fixes before the second round:
- the caption and appeal-sentence filters;
- the prosecution rule;
- the hard-negative rule for the disposition question.
A later in-house read found a footnote's "affirmative defense" being counted as a disposition word. It is now excluded.
Second round: 0 of 60 wrong. The remaining minor issues (partial-win reversals) were removed by the partial-win filter above.
v2. An in-house read of 21 v2 documents (30 questions) found no errors. An independent blind review of 60 v2 documents found 1 wrong (1.7%). That case's head matter states the plaintiff appealed, but a later line says "Defendant appealed." The conflicting-appellant filter above now removes such documents. The review's minor notes concerned OCR noise, an intervening party, a dissent paragraph printed twice in the source, and appeals that reach this court through a lower appeal.
License
CC BY 4.0.
- Downloads last month
- 91